SHAMELESS PLUG: Are you coming to The Rialto on Saturday night in Raleigh? You should! I’m a part of the Rialto Revue with some amazing guests. Tickets are still available. BE THERE.
And now, on to this week’s newsletter and podcast:
The Bonner Bridge, which opened in 1963, immediately had problems. By 1965, work had to be done on the bridge because the inlet underneath it was migrating, meaning boats couldn’t pass under it in the spot where they were supposed to. Plus, the steel corroded, chunks of concrete fell off, and the constant flow of water washed out the sand that kept the supports in place. The bridge underwent major construction in 1978 and 1981 after it was discovered that some of the pilings only went 7 feet into the earth beneath the water.

The construction of the Bonner Bridge across Oregon Inlet in the Outer Banks in the early 1960s. (Photo via NCDOT)
The bridge was also not built to handle large boats smacking into it. In 1990, a barge rammed into a support, and the bridge had to be closed for four months. By then, the bridge was coming to the end of its original lifespan; when it was finished in 1963, it was only supposed to last 30 years.
So in the early 1990s, the state started to figure out what might replace the Bonner Bridge. But the bigger issue may have been the thing that the bridge connected to.
Pea Island, on the south side of the Bonner Bridge, has long been a notoriously shifty stretch of sand, upon which dunes had to be smooshed precariously close to Highway 12. The issue, as engineers and scientists saw it, was that Pea Island might someday shift away from the end of the bridge, meaning you’d cross Oregon Inlet only to land in the ocean.
I’ve been fascinated by this area for a long time. There were two things in particular that stood out. First, the replacement bridge itself. In the early 2000s, state leaders proposed a bold solution: A 17-mile-long bridge that would bypass Pea Island completely, one that would last 100 years.

The NCDOT proposal for a 17-mile-long bridge to bypass Pea Island.
The idea seemed to have momentum… until it didn’t. “You would take the entire DOT construction budget for a year to build that bridge,” Jim Trogdon, the former secretary of the North Carolina Department of Transportation, told me years ago. “We selected an alternative that could never be built.”
That explanation never sat well with Stan Riggs, a former professor at East Carolina University who was pushing for a longer term, sustainable solution. “If we were going to build a 100-year-bridge, we need a 100 year road,” he told me. “A hundred years? Pea Island is eroding faster than that. It was not a pretty picture.”
Obviously, the 17-mile-long bridge didn’t win out. I wanted to know why.
Second: Storms keep knocking down the dunes meant to protect Highway 12 on Pea Island, despite the fact that the Outer Banks haven’t been hit by a hurricane since Dorian in 2019. Over the last few months, nor'easters have left the road looking like this:

Highway 12 earlier this year near the Pea Island Visitor Center on the Outer Banks (NCDOT)
NCDOT had to start operating an emergency ferry to get people on and off Hatteras Island last month, and the road, when it did re-open, has been down to one lane.
So, what do you do with a problem like Pea Island?
For that, I talked to Joy Crist, editor of the Island Free Press. She’s lived on the Outer Banks for three decades, and has worked as a journalist there since 2007. In this episode of the North Carolina Rabbit Hole, we go deep on road that’s cost tens of millions of dollars to fix over the last decade … and keeps getting fixed anyway.
You can also listen to this episode on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

